← Back to Whitepapers
Published 2026-11-13

Reconceptualizing Social Safety Nets & Employment Insurance

The Bottom Line

Honest government starts with honest words: Employment Insurance (EI) is not insurance.

Real insurance is a voluntary plan you choose to buy where your price matches your risk. Canada’s EI system is a mandatory payroll tax taken off every worker’s paycheque and charged to every employer to fund a massive government welfare and redistribution program.

By calling a tax an “insurance premium,” politicians hide how much tax Canadians are really paying. Worse, the current EI system rewards seasonal layoffs while punishing steady, year-round workers who pay into the system for 40 years and lose every dime if they never file a claim.

This paper proposes three common-sense fixes:

  1. Drop the Fake Label: End the separate EI payroll deduction and fold any needed safety-net funding into our single, honest Flat Income Tax.
  2. Focus Strictly on Preventing Homelessness and Hunger: Narrow public emergency relief back to its true purpose—making sure nobody freezes on the street or goes hungry—and deliver that help through local towns and charities.
  3. Let Workers Own Their Own Savings: Let Canadians build their own tax-free personal safety-net savings accounts that they actually own and keep.

1. Why the Current EI System Is Broken

Calling a Tax “Insurance” Tricks Voters

Economists James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock coined the term fiscal illusion to describe how politicians hide the true cost of government. When Ottawa splits taxes into dozens of different deductions on your pay stub—calling them “premiums” or “contributions” instead of taxes—most people don’t realize how much of their hard-earned money the government is actually taking.

You Get What You Incentivize

Harvard economist Martin Feldstein proved that poorly designed unemployment programs actually create more unemployment. In Canada’s current EI system:

  • Steady Workers Subsidize Repeat Layoffs: Workers and businesses in year-round jobs are forced to pay year after year to subsidize industries that lay off their staff every single off-season like clockwork.
  • Different Rules for Different Postal Codes: Requiring far fewer work hours to qualify for EI in certain regions encourages people to stay out of work longer instead of finding year-round jobs or training for new careers.
  • You Don’t Own a Dime of What You Paid: If a hardworking nurse, plumber, or accountant pays into EI for 40 years and never gets laid off, they get $0 back when they retire. The government took it all.

2. The Current EI Fiction vs. An Honest Safety Net

Feature Today’s “Employment Insurance” Fiction Our Honest Safety-Net Model
What It Is Called Disguised as “Insurance Premiums” taken off paycheques on top of income tax. Honestly called a Tax. Separate payroll deductions are scrapped and folded into the single Flat Income Tax voted on by citizens.
What the Money Is For A bloated federal program that subsidizes seasonal layoffs and political pet projects. Strictly targeted emergency help to prevent homelessness and hunger.
Who Delivers the Help A giant, slow federal bureaucracy in Ottawa (Service Canada) with huge overhead costs. Local Delivery: Handled by city governments and trusted local charities that know their community and stretch every dollar.
What Happens to Your Savings Workers who never file a claim lose 100% of the money taken from their paycheques. Workers can put money into tax-free Personal Safety-Net Accounts that belong 100% to them and their family.

3. How This Fits Canadian Law

  • Returning to Canada’s Original Design: Until 1940, helping unemployed and struggling citizens was a local and provincial job under the Constitution (confirmed by the courts in 1937). A wartime amendment in 1940 handed Ottawa control over “Unemployment Insurance,” which ballooned into today’s federal payroll-tax machine.
  • What Needs to Change: Repeal the Employment Insurance Act, abolish separate federal EI payroll taxes on workers and employers, and return emergency shelter and food relief to local communities and charities under Sections 92(7) and 92(16) of the Constitution Act, 1867.

4. What Needs to Happen Next (Action Plan)

  1. Scrap the EI Payroll Tax & Stop Calling It Insurance: Repeal the Employment Insurance Act payroll deduction. Stop calling a tax “insurance.” Any public money needed for basic safety nets must be included openly inside the single Flat Income Tax rate that Canadians vote on at election time.
  2. Focus Strictly on Preventing Homelessness and Hunger: End regional corporate subsidies and seasonal-layoff handouts. Limit government emergency relief strictly to keeping a roof over people’s heads and food on the table during a crisis.
  3. Move Emergency Help to Local Towns & Charities: Hand anti-hunger and emergency shelter funding down to municipal governments and local food banks and shelters, where local oversight stops fraud and maximizes real help per dollar.
  4. Create Tax-Free Personal Safety-Net Accounts: Let workers and employers put money into personal, tax-free savings accounts—or buy real, voluntary private income insurance—so if you never lose your job, you keep every dollar you saved for your retirement or your kids.

5. Further Reading & Sources

Topic Source Why It Matters
Why Personal Accounts Work Better Feldstein, M. (2005). “Rethinking Social Insurance.” American Economic Review. Shows how personal unemployment savings accounts protect workers without encouraging layoffs.
Hidden Payroll Taxes Buchanan, J. M., & Tullock, G. (1962). The Calculus of Consent. University of Michigan Press. Explains how labeling taxes as “insurance premiums” hides the true tax burden from voters.
Original Constitutional Rule Reference re Employment and Social Insurance Act, [1937] A.C. 355. Confirmed that under Canada’s original Constitution, social aid belonged at the local and provincial level.
Who Wins and Loses in Canadian EI Clemens, J., & Palacios, M. (2019). Evaluating Employment Insurance in Canada. Fraser Institute. Documents how Canada’s EI system unfairly taxes steady workers to subsidize seasonal layoffs.
Problems with Federal EI Mendelsohn, M., & Medow, J. (2012). Making EI Work. Mowat Centre, University of Toronto. Highlights the red tape, unfairness, and inefficiency of Ottawa’s centralized EI bureaucracy.