Restructuring Healthcare Delivery via Subsidiarity & User Fees
The Bottom Line
In any system, you get what you incentivize. When a vital service like healthcare is run by a government monopoly and feels completely “free” at the front desk, demand becomes endless while supply is rationed by waiting lists.
That is why Canada’s current healthcare system suffers from months-long waits for surgery, packed emergency rooms, millions of people without a family doctor, and runaway provincial budgets.
This paper proposes a common-sense fix built on three pillars:
- Keep Ottawa Focused on Safety Inspections: Limit the federal government strictly to national disease security and inspecting the safety of food, drugs, and medical devices—100% paid for by licensing fees charged to those industries.
- Move Care Closer to Home: Let provinces, cities, private clinics, and local charities run hospitals and clinics where decisions are made close to patients.
- Small User Fees & Private Competition: Charge a small, clear co-pay for routine clinic visits to prevent overuse (with local charities covering the fee for anyone in poverty) and allow private clinics to build more operating rooms and diagnostic centers.
1. Why the Current System Is Broken
Why “Free” Care Means Waiting in Line
Economists Kenneth Arrow and Charles Tiebout showed that when patients see a $0 price tag at the clinic door and private alternatives are banned, two things go wrong at the same time:
- Overuse of Emergency & Routine Care: Without even a modest front-desk fee, emergency rooms and walk-in clinics get flooded with minor, non-urgent visits that drive up wait times for seriously ill patients.
- A Shortage of Doctors and Beds: Because the government monopoly treats every new hospital bed or surgery as an expense against its budget rather than a service customers are paying for, it restricts the number of operating hours, MRI machines, and doctors.
Adding a modest, upfront user fee for routine visits encourages responsible use, while opening the door to private clinics brings in private investment to build new surgical and diagnostic centers—shortening the line for everyone.
Inspections Should Pay for Themselves
General income taxes shouldn’t be drained by federal health bureaucrats. The government’s job of inspecting pharmaceutical companies, medical device makers, food processors, and hospitals should pay for itself through mandatory commercial licensing and permit fees—and heavy fines when companies break safety rules.
2. Who Should Do What in Healthcare
| Sector | Main Job | How It Is Paid For |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Government | National border health security and strict safety inspections of prescription drugs, medical equipment, and food production. | 100% funded by industry licensing/permit fees and safety fines—zero cost to income taxpayers. |
| Provincial & Local Governments | Running regional hospitals, emergency rooms, and community clinics. | Provincial and local taxes plus small, clear user fees at the clinic door. |
| Private Clinics & Local Charities | Running independent surgery centers, MRI/CT scan clinics, family practices, and charity funds for low-income patients. | Direct patient payments, private health insurance, and tax-free charitable donations. |
3. How This Fits Canadian Law
- You Have a Charter Right to Timely Care: In the landmark 2005 case Chaoulli v. Quebec, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that forcing citizens to suffer on long public waiting lists while banning them from paying for private care violates the right to life and personal security. Simply put: “Access to a waiting list is not access to health care.”
- Hospitals Belong to Provinces, Not Ottawa: Section 92(7) of the Constitution Act, 1867 gives provinces—not the federal government—exclusive authority over establishing and managing hospitals and charities.
- What Needs to Change: Repeal Sections 18 to 21 of the Canada Health Act, which Ottawa currently uses to claw back money from provinces that allow user fees or private clinics.
4. What Needs to Happen Next (Action Plan)
- End Federal Penalties on Provinces: Change the Canada Health Act so provinces are no longer punished financially for allowing small co-pays, private insurance, or private clinics.
- Make Health Canada Self-Funding: Focus Health Canada strictly on real scientific inspections of drugs, medical devices, and food safety, fully paid for by the fees charged to the companies seeking approval.
- Add Small User Co-Pays (With Charity Backstops): Introduce a small, clear fee for non-emergency clinic and testing visits so people think twice before overusing the system, while partnering with local charities to cover the fee for low-income citizens.
- Fast-Track New Private Clinics: Let private doctors and investors who build new surgery centers, diagnostic labs, and clinics write off 100% of their construction and equipment costs in the first year so Canada can rapidly add medical capacity.
5. Further Reading & Sources
| Topic | Source | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Supreme Court Ruling | Chaoulli v. Quebec (Attorney General), 2005 SCC 35. | Ruled that banning private healthcare while failing to provide timely public care violates fundamental rights. |
| Healthcare & Incentives | Arrow, K. J. (1963). “Uncertainty and the Welfare Economics of Medical Care.” American Economic Review. | Explains why co-pays and insurance incentives matter to prevent system overload. |
| Local Choice & Quality | Tiebout, C. M. (1956). “A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures.” Journal of Political Economy. | Shows how local delivery and competition force service providers to stay efficient and responsive. |
| European Comparisons | OECD (2024). Health at a Glance: Europe & OECD Health Statistics. | Shows how countries like Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Germany achieve universal care with much shorter wait times using co-pays and private providers. |
| Canadian Wait-Time Data | Moir, M., & Barua, B. (2024). Waiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada. Fraser Institute. | Tracks how long Canadians wait from seeing a family doctor to getting treatment, and what those delays cost patients. |